Talk:Willow Island

Is 2400,000 square kilometres and 390,000 residents an acceptable size for a small island?  Penguinpuffdude   It's time for a chat, no?    09:36, 13 February 2019 (UTC)


 * To me, the population may be good depending on the size, but the size doesn't make much sense. If it's 2,400,000 sq km, it'd be one of the largest countries irl (11 I think), and even 240,000 sq. km is pretty big, as big as Great Britain. So, I'd recommend either reducing that significantly, or even better removing a number for size altogether, since it doesn't matter much and is hard to discern what that actually means. Could just describe it as a "small island" instead like you said, maybe compare it to another island for an estimate if you wanted to. --  C  K   Admin  15:39, 25 February 2019 (UTC)


 * Personally, I think the exact size of a country is one of those details that's better left ignored. It's less work and no one will really miss it if it's gone :D --Chill57181 (Talk - Contributions  - My Articles )  20:53, 25 February 2019 (UTC)


 * re: CK - ok, I'll cut two zeroes to it and make it 3400; probably size it up a bit to a maximum of 10,000 but the root of the problem is probably my incompetence at maths, but I'll get it consistent in the end. I guess a population ranging from about 4000 to 100,00 would be good for that? Update: decided that I'll make it the same size as Ireland (one of the countries I call "small"), so according to Wikipedia it's 84,421 km2; I guess I would be better off halving it (approx. 42,210 km2) or making it half of Northern Ireland? re: Chill - if everything doesn't go as smoothly as I hope, then I'll take you advice and ditch the numbers, :3  Penguinpuffdude Hiking.png  It's time for a chat, no?    08:42, 26 February 2019 (UTC)


 * Countries are plot dependent size big and from experience it's best not to mention the exact size because it's never going to matter and potentially conflicts with other country sizes that aren't consistent or realistic. Puffle'and is smaller than Britain but story-wise not really. -- User:EDFan 1234  5  12:32, 27 February 2019 (UTC)

42,000 km is still probably decent size in Antarctica, about the size of Switzerland or Denamark irl, not necessarily a "small" island. --  C  K   Admin  08:20, 11 March 2019 (UTC)

"and his dog, Sir Toby Gravy Junior, his hypochondriac, paranoid pet puffle"

Is it a dog, a puffle or a dog puffle? -- Quackerpingu   (Talk)   (Contributions)  06:18, 7 May 2019 (UTC)
 * Oops - I meant to write "puffle", but as I wrote it after flicking through a few pages, it seems that I let out a Fruedian slip; good catch! :)  Penguinpuffdude Hiking.png  It's time for a chat, no?    03:36, 8 May 2019 (UTC)

What is the PETP? Is it Penguins for the Ethical Treatment of Puffles or Puffles for the Ethical Treatment of Penguins? -- Quackerpingu   (Talk)   (Contributions)  09:03, 14 May 2019 (UTC)



-- Quackerpingu   (Talk)   (Contributions)  10:16, 14 May 2019 (UTC)